Reins are the piece of tack you hold the whole ride, and they are how everything you ask gets from your hands to your horse's mouth. I build western reins, split and one-piece, in my shop in Eminence, Indiana, and I ride in split reins myself. This is how I help people pick the right pair, the same questions I ask when someone calls me about reins.
What I ask before I recommend a pair
When someone asks me for reins, the first thing I want to know is whether they already know what they like. So I ask:
- What length do you like?
- What width do you like?
- What material do you like your reins made from?
- Do you want single-ply or doubled and stitched?
If you can answer those four, you are most of the way there. If you can't, the rest of this guide walks through each one.
What types of western reins are there?
The four you will hear about are split reins, roping (one-piece) reins, romal reins and mecate reins.
Split reins
Two separate reins, one for each side of the bit. They are what I ride in, and they are the most versatile rein there is: two hands in a snaffle, one hand in a curb, and everything in between.
Roping or one-piece reins
One continuous rein that connects to both sides of the bit, so there is nothing to drop. I build these a few different ways, including one-piece adjustable reins and laced barrel reins. If you run barrels, my over and under whip buying guide covers the whip side of it.
Romal and mecate reins
I don't build romals or mecates. Every now and then I'll stock a few to resell, but I don't make them myself, and I'd rather tell you that up front.
What length reins do I need?
On average, most people like split reins somewhere around 7 to 7½ feet. But it really depends on the horse and the rider: how much slack you give your horse and how much rein you like in your hand.
The horse matters more than people think. If you ride a short horse in really long reins, they are going to drag the ground. If you ride a big horse with a long, extended neck, short reins just aren't going to be long enough to stay in your hands.
I cut split reins anywhere from 6½ to 8 feet. Tell me the length you want in the note at checkout and that's what you'll get. If you need more than a one-piece rein can give you, I also make rein extensions that add up to 2 feet per side.
Should I get 1/2" or 5/8" reins?
The 1/2" rein is a little narrower and a little lighter. People with smaller hands usually like the 1/2". People with larger hands usually go to the 5/8". Every split rein I make comes in both widths.
Weight, drape and feel
This is the hard part about reins, and it's why I ask for a note with every order. Two reins cut from the same hide can still feel a little different, depending on which part of the hide they came from and how that hide came off the cow. Leather is a natural material and no two sides are exactly alike.
So when you order, leave me a note in the comment section and tell me how you like your reins to feel:
- Do you like a lot of drape?
- Do you like some thickness to them?
- Do you like them weighted or flat?
- What length do you like?
I'll pull the set that matches you best or cut a fresh pair. Both reins in a pair are always cut side by side from the same side of leather, so they drape the same, feel the same and break in together.
Single-ply or doubled and stitched?
My standard split reins are single-ply harness leather: one layer, with a direct feel and a quick break-in. I also build doubled and stitched split reins, which are two layers of latigo sewn together with weighted ends. They are heavier and have more drape. Neither one is better than the other. It's about the feel you want in your hand. If you want to know how harness leather and latigo differ, read harness vs bridle vs latigo leather.
Water loops, buckle ends or snaps?
Here's how I do it on my own horses. If the reins are going to stay on one bridle, I use water loops. If I'm going to move reins from bridle to bridle, I use buckle ends.
Snaps are very convenient, but they are one more thing in the equation that can fail at some point. I use stainless steel on all of my snaps so they don't rust, and I buy the best ones I can find. Even so, dirt and sand can build up in them and cause a snap to fail. If you use snaps, keep an eye on them, keep them clean and make sure they stay in good condition. A little oil won't hurt, though most people won't need it.
On my buckle-end reins I use stainless steel buckles. For where the reins fit in with the rest of the bridle, see parts of a western bridle.
How can you tell if reins are cheap?
A lot of cheap reins don't have much body to them. The leather has no condition. It's dry and thin, and the fibers aren't very dense. Those reins won't necessarily fail, but they won't give you the feel you need, or the feel your horse needs. A good rein has the weight and density to carry your timing from the moment a cue leaves your hands to the moment it reaches your horse's mouth. A light, lifeless rein loses some of that along the way.
My reins at a glance
| Rein | Leather | Bit end | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dark Oil Split Reins | Single-ply harness | Water loops | $75 |
| Split Reins with Buckle Ends | Single-ply harness | Stainless buckles | $97 |
| Doubled and Stitched Split Reins | Latigo, two layers, weighted ends | Water loops | $125 |
| One-Piece Adjustable Reins | Latigo | Stainless scissor snaps | $49 |
| Laced Barrel Reins | Latigo core, chrome tan lace | Stainless swivel snaps | $84 |
You can see every set in the reins collection.
How do I take care of leather reins?
The biggest mistake I see is people not cleaning their reins often enough. Arena sand gets into the fibers and works just like sandpaper. You don't need a deep clean every day, but run a stiff brush or a rag over them to get the dirt and sand off.
When I do clean them, I brush them off, wash them with a liquid saddle soap, let them dry completely, and put on a thin coat of a good conditioner like Skidmore's. Then I let that sit for a day and wipe them down with saddle soap one more time to take off any tacky feel. Don't douse them in oil. My reins already come oiled and conditioned, and too much oil leaves them feeling wet and nasty. The full routine is in how to clean and condition leather.
If you ever want me to do it for you, I'll clean and condition anything I sell for free, for life. Get it to me and I'll ship it back at my cost.
My lifetime warranty
Everything I make has a lifetime warranty. It covers anything that breaks or fails in normal use. Parts that wear with use, like latigos and off billets, aren't covered once they've worn out. If it can be repaired, I'll repair it. If it can't, I'll replace it, at no charge. If you have any questions, contact me. The details are on the warranty and leather care page.
Leather built from the very best materials, with the best craftsmanship you can put into it, should last forever. It might cost a little more up front, but it's cheaper in the long run.
Frequently asked questions
What length split reins do I need?
Most riders like split reins around 7 to 7½ feet, but it depends on your horse, how much slack you give and how much rein you like in your hand. A short horse needs shorter reins so they don't drag. A big horse with a long neck needs longer ones. I cut split reins from 6½ to 8 feet; leave your length in the note at checkout.
Should I get 1/2" or 5/8" reins?
The 1/2" rein is narrower and a little lighter, and it usually suits smaller hands. The 5/8" usually suits larger hands. All of my split reins come in both widths.
Are water loops, buckle ends or snaps better?
I use water loops when the reins stay on one bridle and buckle ends when I move reins between bridles. Snaps are convenient, but they are one more thing that can fail. Mine are stainless steel, but dirt and sand can still build up in them, so keep them clean and check them often.
What's the difference between single-ply and doubled and stitched reins?
Single-ply reins are one layer of leather, with a direct feel and a quick break-in. My single-ply split reins are harness leather. Doubled and stitched reins are two layers sewn together. Mine are latigo with weighted ends, so they are heavier and have more drape. It comes down to the feel you like.
Do you make romal or mecate reins?
No. I build split reins and one-piece reins. I sometimes stock romals or mecates to resell, but I don't make them myself.
How do I clean leather reins?
Brush off the dirt and sand, wash with a liquid saddle soap, let them dry completely, then apply a thin coat of conditioner like Skidmore's. Let it sit a day and wipe them down with saddle soap again to remove any tackiness. Don't soak them in oil.
Tyler has been building Western tack for more than fifteen years, the last six of them full time, from the shop at his house in Eminence, Indiana. Growing up around some of the top professionals in the pleasure horse, barrel racing and racehorse worlds gave him the chance to ride high-quality horses in each of those disciplines, and years spent as a pickup man and riding ranch horses today are where most of his ideas for better tack come from. Every piece he builds is made in the USA and guaranteed for life.
